e.m. moulton
" And in Him you too
are being built together to become a dwelling in
which God lives by His Spirit."
~ Ephesians 2:19
"The
architect is a molder of men, whether or not he
consciously assumes the responsibility."
~ Frank Lloyd Wright
What shapes a life? What shapes the soul of a people?
What structures exist under God and through God's
purpose and will that molds and fashions humanity?
Obviously, the ministry of the church plays the
most significant role in shaping people for the
Kingdom of God. Our ministries to students play
a significant role in shaping lives. Certainly,
God is using many other people and structures to
reach and shape students, but what a sobering thought
it is when we consider the shaping influence our
ministries have on students. Therefore, the architecture
and design of the ministries must never be neglected
or haphazard. Ministry architecture and design
plays a critical role in determining the ethos
of a community of people. In the white harvest
fields of youth culture, youth ministry architecture
should be a huge consideration.
Since Noah's construction
of the Ark, definable worship architecture and
space has played a major
role in life, particularly for the people of God.
Buildings, structure and other created environments
impact us and contribute to the shaping of people.
Likewise, the "space" of ministry contributes
significantly to the shaping of people.
For centuries, artists have
constructed sacred spaces so that people could
engage God and experience His
presence. The world of art and architecture has rich
and necessary link to the things of God and to the
people of God. Great architecture flows from the
heart of God. God is and has always been the master
architect. From the moment God spoke and created
our world He has revealed Himself in part as an architect,
as creator. He took a formless, dark and empty world
and constructed an environment that declared His
majesty. It became a perfect environment to house
a people, made in His image, reflecting His Glory
and residing in perfect fellowship with Him. God's
architectural works not only shape lives but in fact,
sustain them. No where else does form and function
reside with better harmony and balance. Certain constructed
spaces evoke unique feelings and convey certain messages.
Our homes make statements regarding tastes, style,
priority and values. Everything from the color choices
of paint to the landscape to the to the selection
of décor speak and impact and inform. Consequently,
as people created in the image of God, the impulse
to create and construct is a part of our make-up.
It's in the hardwire.
For God's people, the construction of sacred worship
space has a high priority. And this priority is given
by God Himself. Since the days of Noah's Ark to the
altar's of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, the tabernacle
of Moses and the Temple of Solomon, we have been
keenly aware of the relationship between constructed
space and the worship of God. These spaces remind
us of the majesty, the power and the glory of God
(at least they should). They provide inspiration
and speak metaphorically of who God is and who we
are in Christ. We tend to think of artistry and architecture
solely in terms of tangible creations, but there
is more art and more architecture to be created that
lies hidden in the unseen realm.
The birth of the Church
and the ushering in of the New Covenant brought
on radical changes and implications
for the idea of "sacred space" and spiritual
architecture. Because of the radical shift in the
dwelling place of God's Spirit, from the temple to
the body (the temple of the Holy Spirit), the architecture
of the Kingdom becomes increasingly less tangible.
Certainly, tangible architecture is still important,
but more so for the metaphorical implications. The
outward structures serve to remind us of the inward
realities of being the temple of the Holy Spirit.
Several years ago, my wife and I and some friends
visited the monastery in Conyers, GA. The enormous
sanctuary/cathedral (constructed by the monks themselves
in the 1940's) was awe inspiring. Entering the building
ignited a sense of the holy and divine. The vaulted,
ribbed ceiling and the powerful silence moved us
to fearful worship of the Holy God. The immaculate
nature of the facility evoked reminders of purity
and God's shear glory. Chatting together after this
experience reminded us that the reverence and holiness
and purity of that sanctuary is what the inner recesses
of our hearts should look like as the dwelling place
of the Holy Spirit of God. The space literally taught
and reinforced the some of the attributes of the
God we worship. The physical architecture of the
cathedral was a powerful metaphorical image of the
reality within as Christians. God is not confined
to buildings, but dwells in the hearts of those who
receive Him.
This brings us to the key thought, the architecture of student ministry. The
greatest works of art or architecture are not tangible at all, but are those
hidden places of the human heart that are given wholly over to Christ. Beauty,
as the apostle Peter describes it, is not solely in outward things, but dwells
most profoundly within the "hidden person of the heart." When we
see the Lord constructing in our young people a temple unto Him or see them
becoming a dynamic spiritual house, it is without doubt the most beautiful
thing. These creations (a life given to God in discipleship) are always the
most intricate, complex, compelling and bring the greatest glory to God.
The preparatory ministry of Jesus with the disciples
is the first and finest example of ministry architecture
of the Spirit. It was a ministry that had very
little physical or tangible architecture. But His
training of the twelve had spiritual structure
and design galore. For Jesus, the youth room, that
relevant place of ministry and identity, was found
on the streets of Capernaum and on the stormy Galillean
Sea. The evangelism training laboratory was the
local city context itself! He created an unforgettable
ethos in that short, three-year period. It was
more than theological knowledge, but direct, intimate
interaction with truth itself. He created environments
(by the Father's design) that challenged and pushed
the disciples. He orchestrated moments of divine
tension and opened revelatory Kingdom windows by
preaching in powerful metaphorical images and stories.
In the house of Jesus' ministry were rooms of conviction,
revelation, affirmation, failure, repentance, healing,
freedom and joy. His leadership showed an attitude
of reverence, submission, joy, abandon and ultimate
freedom and security. In one fluid motion Jesus
established a ministry that had no building but
had plenty of architecture and "Spirit Design".
The Gospel accounts of Jesus' ministry to the disciples
show a rhythmic flow between evangelism, edification,
equipping, etc. It is difficult to find the hard
lines dividing outreach from discipleship and vice
versa. They both seem to feed off each other.
We recognize the importance of space and environment in youth ministry. How
many youth pastors over the years have fought the elder board for a youth
room or for more youth space? These spaces play a role (we believe) in the
shaping of a relevant identity for students and student ministry. In an experience-driven,
multi-sensory 21st century youth culture, the architecture of youth ministry
becomes something that must be taken seriously. Andy Stanley and Stuart Hall,
in their book, The Seven Checkpoints, speak of the importance of establishing
a context for the content of ministry. Relevant ministry context for a savvy,
sensory sensitive culture is huge. For the youthworker this presents a daunting
range of possibilities when it comes to creating ministry environments and
experiences. The idea of ministry context is a compelling one. In his book,
An Unstoppable Force, Erwin Mcmanus pops open the idea of pastors and church
leaders being "cultural architects" and coins a chapter title "Spirit
Design Theory". Mcmanus spends a lot of time describing how a church
creates an "ethos" (for better or for worse). The architecture
travels far beyond a room or meeting space. It involves the attitude, the
heart, the expectation and the tone of the ministry. The concept of youth
ministry architecture runs much deeper than choosing posters for the youth
meeting space. Your ministry is literally shaping lives. The environment
you create through within the ministry carries tremendous potential and responsibility.
This also goes beyond having a mission statement or list of core values (although
these play an important role). Every ministry carries with it certain shape,
a form and unique design. The components, being many and varied, are both
visible and invisible. Mcmanus states,
 |
True leadership
affects the soul of an organization and the spirit
Of the people…We need to recapture the invisible aspects of
Leadership. We must focus our attention on the creating and shaping
Of ethos and then on the structures that best nurture and
Harness its potential. In the end leadership is nothing less than spiritual.
And spiritual leaders are essentially cultural architects. |
It is vital that we construct
environments that are more than information gathering
times. Our role
as soul architects must encompass more than the dispensing
of theological knowledge for students. It must encompass
more than mere social opportunity as well. We must
create deliberate community developing whole disciples
for Christ. They must have experiential learning
environments. The postmodern student is an "experiential
learner". In the words of Leonard Sweet,
 |
"Many attention-deficit-disorder
kids are really multiple kinesthetics: postmodern,
electronic kids who learn not through lockstep,
lecture-drill-test marches of the industrial
age but through multi-sensory webs of stimulation
and inspiration." |
Frank Lloyd Wright is without doubt, the most influential
figure in the field of architecture in twentieth
century America. His innovations in both commercial
and residential architecture gave America, in many
ways, its own unique architectural identity. One
of the significant architectural innovations that
Wright pioneered was the idea of "Organic
Architecture". Organic architecture ushered
in new possibilities for home spaces that were,
at the time, under a heavy Victorian influence.
Instead of boxy, strictly defined rooms, Wright
helped "…create the open plan with rooms
that opened each other." One essay concerning
Wright's organic architecture describes it like
this,
 |
Wright
hated the "box". At the time of Wright's
entrance to
architecture, most houses and structures were boxy with no
originality or individuality. His organic principles called for an
open house design, and an easy flow between the outside
environment and the inside of the building.
The box was containment.
It contained within everything. It was
living or ought to be living. Whereas the new idea was to eliminate
the box and let everything that was in go outward and associate with
its environment. The "box" design set limitations of space, which
was against all the basic ideas of organic architecture. |
The stress on Wright's organic concept is that each
component of the site, structure and material should
build towards a whole and unified work. The form
and function begin to merge as one working unit,
with one complimenting the other. One of the greatest
challenges and responsibilities of a youth worker
is to seek the from the beginning. Doing youth ministry
without a vision of what we want our students to
look like as they mature in Christ is futile. A student
ministry should never be a haphazard collision of
programs and trips, but a series of environments
and expeditions aimed at cultivating whole disciples.
For those of us involved in Youth Ministry, perhaps
we need to explore a more organic discipleship
architecture. Remove all unnecessary walls and
boundaries preventing students from developing
a whole-life view of their faith in Christ.
The implications for youth ministry in a de-compartmentalized,
postmodern world are enormous at best and intriguing
at very least. Wright's innovations in architecture
provide an archetype for the kinds of radical shifts
that perhaps need to be made for more effective youth
ministry. Taking Wright's cues, let's consider several
departures from old architectural forms:
Like the boxed, strictly
defined Victorian architecture that Wright deconstructed,
modern ministry constructs
tended to create many of the same clean lines. In
a world dominated by compartments, ministry to students
tended to follow suit. For example, the concept of
outreach we relegated to nursing home visits or an
annual mission trip. The concept of evangelism was
relegated certain, specific outings or trips where
we asked students to "share" their faith
and, rather than these becoming a lifestyle, it became
something you do when the youth group program calendar
calls for it. Somehow, subconsciously, we constructed
lines that kept evangelism separate from "real
life" and the everyday world. It is similar
to the idea that been perpetuated confusing the office
of the evangelist described by Paul in Ephesians
and the responsibility of every believer to be a
witness, described by Jesus throughout the gospels
and specifically in Acts1:8.
"Sacramentalize" everything. Throw away
the compartmentalized nature of faith. Create a ministry
that refuses separate rooms, but one flowing space
that is in every way and in every place invaded by
God. The need to "de-compartmentalize" is
long over due. Several years ago while shopping at
the mall, I felt led to approach a group of junior
high girls to share Christ with them and to encourage
them with God's love. At some point in the course
of our exchange, one of the girls boldly and defiantly
declared, "Oh, that Jesus thing? I already did
that!" So many young people (and dare I say,
us adults?) live in this incredibly compartmentalized
world of a different mask for each segment of their
lives. Because we have compartmentalized salvation
into a hand raised at camp rather than a way of life
to enter into through repentance and relationship
with Christ, their faith is summed up in one brief
moment's response. And frankly, 85% of what they
hear throughout the remainder of their time in the
youth ministry is aimed at getting other students
to make the same response. What would happen in youth
ministries if the compartmentalization of the "Holy
Moment" were enlarged so that every moment became
Holy unto the Lord? What would happen if we tore
apart the sacred spaces in our ministry and cried
out to God to allow every space and event to be sacred
unto Him?
Seeing all of life as a
sacramental teaches students that worship is more
than a song, that witnessing
is more than an event and that service is more than
a quarterly project. Striving for a whole-life approach
breaks the barriers of a compartmentalized faith
and ministry. It is the idea that evangelism is a
whole life idea; that worship is a whole life idea.
With this type of ministry ethos, or structure, mission
becomes so much more than a weeklong summer experience,
it becomes an everyday awareness. Missions are not
in a "room down the hall", it’s a
reality I see right now, and it's the reality of
the world where I stand.
In a metaphorical sense, your ministry to students is a studio of Spirit design.
The interior spaces are devoted to the craft of loving God. Sacred spaces for
worship and disciplines, spaces of community and nurture. These spaces are
strategic and intentional, designed to connect the creator with the created.
Here, the young artists in your ministry discover their identity in the Master,
Jesus Christ. They discover relationships with peers that spur them on in artistry
of discipleship. While the interior spaces tend to emphasize the interior of
a young disciple, it is not limited interior experiences only and vice versa.
Just as the Holy Spirit is a teacher in the sanctuary and in the streets, so
our ministry studio will be. Your greatest teaching may very come outside a
youth room. The inside space is never for nothing, it is never wasted, but
is always economized. Youth Ministry artists treasure the commodities of time
and resources and never pour out anything for just nothing.
 The outside spaces of the
ministry studio push the artistry into the fields
where doors of opportunity
swing on ready. Here the studio becomes a field lab
where young disciples join in the work of the master
craftsman to color and flavor the world with the
Kingdom song. Here the studio becomes a platform
for humble service and grace-filled living- a display
of art for the world to witness. Mission trips, outreaches
within the community and other group outings create
the studio of the ministry in the "live" world
setting. Here, the work of the inside space is put
to the test and refined in fire. Here, the young
disciple artists expand their horizons and feel the
pulse God - his heart-beat for the world.

Both the inside and outside architectural elements
thrive and feed on one another ( see Philemon v.6).
And this is the genius behind Frank Lloyd Wright's
organic architecture. His interior spaces blended
with the exterior to form one whole, one unified
work. Our ministries to students fall down when we
fail to cultivate the interior and exterior of discipleship.
In fact, a strong exterior without a correspondingly
strong interior will not be effective. Amazingly,
this interior/exterior often becomes interchangeable.
Evangelism happens in the interior and nurture happens
on the street because God is looking to shape us
and direct us and win people to himself all the time,
everywhere! Your most powerful prayer session could
happen on the side of the road and your most poignant
outreach could happen in the youth room.
One of Wright's desires was to see the building
blend with the natural surroundings, to embrace the
existing environment. Obviously, the biblical mandate
is to be in the world, yet not of the world. The
incarnation provides the strongest mandate for contextual
ministry. The act of God encasing himself in human
flesh with all its vulnerabilities in order to redeem
mankind should motivate us in constructing ministries
relative to our local cultural context. In fact,
Wright used construction materials that were from
the existing environment and that reflected the natural
surroundings. He wanted the interior spaces to flow
into the exterior spaces with a certain harmony.
For too long we have structured church as a fortress
from the world and not a community bearing light
and hope for the world. For so long we have built
fortresses and gates to keep ourselves unspotted
by the world and now its time to invade the environment
and surroundings with redemptive hope. Instead cloistering
a community of students away from the world, let's
equip a community of students to infiltrate their
cultural context with the burning light of Christ.
What are the cultural distinctives that mark your
community. What are the native distinctives? How
is your ministry embracing those to bring the gospel?
These elements will be unique to each community and
creates opportunity for a more organic ministry.
As we ride into the first quarter of the 21C, I
believe we will begin to see whole new paradigms
of youth ministry. As we shift away culturally from
a more modern form of education and ministry strategy,
the youthworker as architect becomes increasingly
important. The experiential and the participatory
elements of the learning and discipleship process
for youth ministry is crucial. Perhaps this is one
reason that worship has exploded recent years. Worship
invites participation. In worship, we experience
the presence of God in powerful ways. Through worship,
students are able to corporately and individually
cry out to the Father. Through worship, people experience
more than an object lesson or illustration, they
get God himself!
The day of mere intellectual transference of Bible
facts and knowledge is over. Youth ministries that
do not help lead students into the presence of God
(and into the world in the presence of God) and ignite
them for incarnational ministry are quickly becoming
obsolete. That is why the craft and art of the youth
worker is crucial. We do not put together programs,
we construct environments and opportunities for students
to engage God. We must begin to construct environments
that invite students to participate in the active
pursuit of knowing and experiencing God.
Your youth ministry is a studio. The studio runs
from the sanctuary to the student meeting room and
bleeds out into the streets, into the schools and
avenues, coffee shops, malls and homes- wherever
students dwell. Your ministry studio is where the
lost are recreated in Christ. It's where students
practice the art of discipleship. The studio is where
people try and fail and try and succeed and are encouraged
to try again. The studio is where young followers
of Jesus are trained, molded, crafted and fashioned
for the master.
Is your ministry confined to a box? Let's tear down
some walls.
Download a PDF file of this article>
 |
Wright, Frank Lloyd 1 Peter 3:3-4 Jesus was not entirely without physical ministry
space. The Gethsemane garden, the synagogue and the upper room served as physical
faith structures,
among others.
It was the reliance on the Holy Spirit to create "Holy Ground" that
made Jesus ministry so powerful, unique and world-altering! Hall, Stuart & Stanley,
Andy The Seven Checkpoints, 2001 Howard Publishing
CO. P. xv Mcmanus, Erwin R. An Unstoppable Force: Daring to Become the Church
God had in
Mind 2001 Group Pulishing P. 135 Sweet, Leonard SoulTsunami, 1998 Zondervan p.
211 http://www.franklloydwright.com/02FLLW/theman.html Littlefield, Caitlin The
Innovations of Frank Lloyd Wright, (an essay) http://cityhonors.buffalo.k12.ny.us/city/aca/hist/arch/wrgtlit/index.html
For an interesting study of the importance of systemic thinking in ministry,
see the book A is for Abductive, by Sweet, Mclaren and Haselmayer, p. 272 I stole
this term from Leonard Sweet. He details this concept in his excellent book,
SoulSalsa. In the defininition of "sacramental", Sweet points
out that it is something that communicates grace, whereas a sacrament is a conveyor
of grace- instituted by God.
|